Why They Died™ All source pages

Volume 3 · American Retail · Chapter 2 · R02

The Man Who Would Not Buy Paint

Montgomery Ward: the first everything store, and the chairman who was right once

The chapter in one paragraph

Montgomery Ward invented the catalog and money-back guarantee, then sat out the postwar suburban boom because its chairman was sure a depression was coming. It never came.

Sources and further reading

  1. The April 1944 seizure and the carried-out photograph, including Avery's "New Dealer" retort to Attorney General Francis Biddle: "U.S. at War: Seizure!," *Time*, May 8, 1944; History.com, "FDR Seizes Control of Montgomery Ward"; American Heritage Center, "Defiance and Consequences: The Montgomery Ward Seizure," December 27, 2018; Matthew Waxman and Samuel Weitzman, "Remembering the Montgomery Ward Seizure," Lawfare, April 25, 2020. Avery's "throw them out the window" credo: "Retail Trade: The Man at the Top," *Time*, November 14, 1960.
  2. Founding (1872 single-sheet catalog; 1875 guarantee; Grange context): "Montgomery Ward," Wikipedia; Britannica, "Montgomery Ward & Co." (retrieved July 2026).
  3. The Wood rejection (Ward president Theodore Merseles fired Wood in 1924 on learning he was negotiating with Sears) and his move to Sears: "Montgomery Ward & Co., Inc.," *International Directory of Company Histories*, via Encyclopedia.com; James C. Worthy, "Sears Roebuck: General Robert E. Wood's Retail Strategy," *Business and Economic History*, 2nd ser., vol. 9; "Robert E. Wood," Wikipedia.
  4. Avery's postwar freeze (no new stores after the war; a hoard of $327 million in cash and government securities), his executive turnover (four presidents and forty vice presidents in twenty-four years), and the 1955 Wolfson proxy fight: "Retail Trade: The Man at the Top," *Time*, November 14, 1960; "Business: Avery Out, Expansion Up," *Time*, May 4, 1959; "Montgomery Ward & Co., Inc.," *International Directory of Company Histories*, via Encyclopedia.com; "Sewell Avery," Wikipedia.
  5. Rudolph (Robert L. May, 1939, 2.4M copies; copyright gift): Smithsonian Institution, "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer"; Chicago History Museum; NPR, December 2015.
  6. Mobil acquisition (majority stake 1974; full merger 1976), catalog closure (1985, after 113 years), and the $3.8 billion 1988 management buyout led by Bernard Brennan with GE Capital: Britannica, "Montgomery Ward & Co."; "Montgomery Ward's LBO Could Be on Its Last Legs," *Bloomberg Businessweek*, September 22, 1996.
  7. Chapter 11 (July 1997), GE Capital control, and the December 28, 2000 liquidation announcement (250 stores, 37,000 jobs): UPI, "Montgomery Wards closing stores," December 28, 2000; PBS NewsHour, "Store Closing: Montgomery Ward"; "Montgomery Ward," Wikipedia.
  8. Sears-versus-Ward sales in the mid-1950s (Ward at roughly one-third of Sears's $3 billion): "Montgomery Ward & Co., Inc.," *International Directory of Company Histories*, via Encyclopedia.com; "Business: Avery Out, Expansion Up," *Time*, May 4, 1959.
  9. Brand revival as catalog and web retailer (Colony Brands era): "Montgomery Ward," Wikipedia (retrieved July 2026).

Corrections and updates

No corrections recorded for this chapter. Found an error? Write to corrections@whytheydied.com and it will be listed here.

Source notes fact-checked 2026-09-23. Updated 2026-09-23