Why They Died™ All source pages

Volume 3 · American Retail · Chapter 3 · R03

Convicted of Low Prices

A&P: the biggest retailer on Earth for forty years, prosecuted by its government, embalmed by its heirs

The chapter in one paragraph

A&P ran nearly sixteen thousand stores and was prosecuted for selling food too cheaply. The government failed to kill it. Its heirs succeeded.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Danville conviction (September 1946; Judge Walter Lindley; the Hartfords' ages; harm-to-competitors framing) and the definitive account of the company overall: Marc Levinson, *The Great A&P and the Struggle for Small Business in America* (2011), this chapter's principal source; excerpt via NPR, August 2011.
  2. Peak store count (15,709, 1930) and ~10% of US grocery spending (1940s): "A&P," Wikipedia; Levinson (2011).
  3. Founding (1859), Gilman's showmanship, Hartford succession: "A&P," Wikipedia; Britannica, "Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company"; FundingUniverse company history.
  4. The 1912 economy store model and its expansion (about 400 stores in 1912; 1,600 by 1915; 4,638 in 1920; about 14,000 by 1925, roughly five new stores a day): Levinson (2011); A&P, "Milestones" (company history, 2004); Britannica Money, "Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company, Inc."; Groceteria.com, "A&P History."
  5. The late-1930s supermarket self-replacement (about 15,400 stores in 1929 cut to 7,250 by 1940, roughly 8,000 closed, while sales grew): Levinson (2011); A&P, "Milestones" (company history, 2004); NPR, "How the A&P Changed the Way We Shop," August 23, 2011.
  6. WEO campaign (1972) and its industry-wide price war: "A&P," Wikipedia; Encyclopedia.com company history.
  7. Tengelmann control (1979), Pathmark acquisition ($1.4B, 2007): "A&P," Wikipedia; contemporaneous coverage, *The New York Times*, 2007.
  8. Chapter 11 (December 12, 2010), 2012 emergence (Yucaipa, Mount Kellett, Goldman funds, $490M), and the July 2015 "Chapter 22" with final closures by late November 2015 (~28,000 employees): "A&P," Wikipedia; DailyDAC, "The A&P Chapter 22 Bankruptcy Saga"; Progressive Grocer, July 2015.
  9. The antitrust legacy and its modern Amazon echoes: "Antitrust in the Internet Era: The Legacy of United States v. A&P," *Review of Industrial Organization* (2019); Levinson (2011).
  10. John Hartford's death (September 1951, in a Chrysler Building elevator after a Chrysler board meeting) and George's (1957): "John A. Hartford Dies in Elevator," *New York Times*, September 21, 1951; Levinson (2011); A&P, "Milestones" (company history, 2004).
  11. The A&P Gypsies radio program (A&P-sponsored, 1924–1936), Eight O'Clock Coffee's standing, and anti-chain-store politics (state taxes; the Patman "death sentence" bill; Louisiana's 1934 tax graduated by a chain's nationwide store count under Huey Long's machine, upheld in *Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. Grosjean*, 301 U.S. 412 [1937]): Levinson (2011); Luther F. Sies, *Encyclopedia of American Radio, 1920–1960* (2014); A&P, "Milestones" (company history, 2004).

Corrections and updates

No corrections recorded for this chapter. Found an error? Write to corrections@whytheydied.com and it will be listed here.

Source notes fact-checked 2026-09-23. Updated 2026-09-23