Why They Died™ All source pages

Volume 3 · American Retail · Chapter 8 · R08

Fired for Being Good

Circuit City: the twin that chose the spreadsheet

The chapter in one paragraph

In March 2007 Circuit City fired its 3,400 best-paid salespeople for being paid too much. Two years later, the company was gone.

Sources and further reading

  1. Wage management (announced March 28, 2007; about 3,400 store associates "paid well above the market-based salary range for their role"; combined cost actions projected to cut fiscal 2008 SG&A by about $110 million and by at least $140 million a year from fiscal 2009): Circuit City Stores, Inc., Form 8-K and press release, March 28, 2007; Ylan Q. Mui, "Circuit City Cuts 3,400 'Overpaid' Workers," *The Washington Post*, March 29, 2007.
  2. Chapter 11 (November 10, 2008), liquidation announcement (January 16, 2009; 567 domestic stores; "more than 30,000 employees"), final closures (March 8, 2009): Circuit City Stores, Inc., Form 8-K and press release, January 16, 2009; contemporaneous coverage, Reuters and AP, 2008–09. Blockbuster proposal (February 17, 2008; made public April 14, 2008; withdrawn July 1, 2008): Blockbuster Inc., Form 8-K, April 14, 2008, and Form 10-Q, August 15, 2008.
  3. DIVX (1997–1999; operations ceased June 16, 1999; after-tax losses of $68.5 million in fiscal 1999 and $16.2 million in fiscal 2000 plus a $114.0 million after-tax loss on disposal): Circuit City Stores, Inc., Fiscal 2001 Annual Report (SEC, May 23, 2001); "DIVX," Wikipedia; contemporaneous coverage.
  4. Appliance exit (announced late July 2000; appliances 14 percent of fiscal 2000 sales): Circuit City Stores, Inc., Fiscal 2001 Annual Report (SEC, May 23, 2001); "Circuit City Stores, Inc. History," *International Directory of Company Histories* (via FundingUniverse).
  5. Founding (Sam Wurtzel, 1949, Richmond), the superstore era, and the definitive insider post-mortem: Alan Wurtzel, *Good to Great to Gone: The 60 Year Rise and Fall of Circuit City* (2012), this chapter's principal source.
  6. *Good to Great* canonization (2001) and its aftermath as management-literature cautionary tale: Jim Collins, *Good to Great* (2001); subsequent commentary; framing per Wurtzel (2012).
  7. CarMax incubation (1993) and spin-off (2002): "CarMax," Wikipedia.
  8. 2003 commission abolition (early February 2003; about 3,900 commissioned salespeople dismissed and about 2,100 hourly workers hired): Circuit City Stores, Inc., Form 10-K for fiscal 2003 (SEC, May 27, 2003); "Circuit City Stores, Inc. History," *International Directory of Company Histories* (via FundingUniverse).

Corrections and updates

No corrections recorded for this chapter. Found an error? Write to corrections@whytheydied.com and it will be listed here.

Source notes fact-checked 2026-09-23. Updated 2026-09-23