The chapter in one paragraph
Ron Johnson abolished J.C. Penney's coupons and lost $4.3 billion in revenue in a year. Around it, the 2017–2023 extinction wave took the middle of American retail.
Sources and further reading
- Johnson's hiring (announced June 2011; took office November 2011), the Fair and Square launch (January–February 2012), and the no-testing conviction ("We didn't test at Apple," as reported by the *Wall Street Journal*, February 25, 2013): "Ron Johnson (businessman)," Wikipedia; *Fortune*, March 5, 2013; D Magazine, "Who Wrecked J.C. Penney?," November 2013.
- The experiment's toll (first-quarter 2012 comparable sales down 18.9 percent; fiscal 2012 comparable sales down 25.2 percent, net sales down from $17.26 billion to $12.99 billion, net loss $985 million) and the April 8, 2013 firing: J.C. Penney earnings releases, May 15, 2012 and February 27, 2013, and Form 8-K, April 8, 2013 (SEC EDGAR); TIME, May 17, 2012. The share of goods sold at deep discount before 2012 is as stated by management at the January 2012 launch.
- Ullman's return, the apology advertisement, and non-returning customers: contemporaneous coverage, May 2013 onward.
- Founding history (Kemmerer 1902; The Golden Rule; associates model): "JCPenney," Wikipedia; Forbes, "From Its Beginnings to Bankruptcy," May 17, 2020.
- Chapter 11 (May 15, 2020; about $5 billion in debt, including a $1.25 billion revolver draw in March 2020) and the Simon and Brookfield landlord purchase (about $800 million, approved November 2020): J.C. Penney Form 10-K, FY2019, and Form 8-K, May 15, 2020 (SEC EDGAR); CNBC, May 15, 2020; Financier Worldwide; "JCPenney," Wikipedia.
- Wave chronology and closure records (more than 8,000 closures announced in 2017; 9,302 announced in 2019, per Coresight; the 2020 filings cohort; Bed Bath & Beyond's $11.7 billion in share repurchases, fiscal 2004–2022, and 2023 liquidation; Party City's 2023 Chapter 11 and 2024–25 liquidation): Bed Bath & Beyond Forms 10-K (SEC EDGAR); CNN Business, January 8, 2020; contemporaneous coverage (CNBC, Retail Dive, *Fortune*, *San Francisco Chronicle*); "Retail apocalypse," Wikipedia.
- Survivor mechanics (Walmart and Target omnichannel build-out; Costco's wage-and-renewal model, with renewal rates of 92.3 percent in the U.S. and Canada and 89.8 percent worldwide in fiscal 2025; TJX, off-price, and dollar-store countertrend): Costco Wholesale Form 10-K, fiscal 2025 (SEC EDGAR); company filings and coverage.
- Penney store count today (roughly 650 as of 2025) and going-concern status inside Catalyst Brands (formed January 2025 with Brooks Brothers, Aéropostale, Lucky Brand, and Nautica; owned by Simon and Brookfield): J.C. Penney Form 10-K, FY2019 (SEC EDGAR); Catalyst Brands corporate website; contemporaneous coverage, January 2025.
Corrections and updates
No corrections recorded for this chapter. Found an error? Write to corrections@whytheydied.com and it will be listed here.