Why They Died™ All source pages

Volume 3 · American Retail · Chapter 12 · R12

Fair and Square

J.C. Penney and the extinction wave: the cleanest experiment in the book, and the wing still under construction

The chapter in one paragraph

Ron Johnson abolished J.C. Penney's coupons and lost $4.3 billion in revenue in a year. Around it, the 2017–2023 extinction wave took the middle of American retail.

Sources and further reading

  1. Johnson's hiring (announced June 2011; took office November 2011), the Fair and Square launch (January–February 2012), and the no-testing conviction ("We didn't test at Apple," as reported by the *Wall Street Journal*, February 25, 2013): "Ron Johnson (businessman)," Wikipedia; *Fortune*, March 5, 2013; D Magazine, "Who Wrecked J.C. Penney?," November 2013.
  2. The experiment's toll (first-quarter 2012 comparable sales down 18.9 percent; fiscal 2012 comparable sales down 25.2 percent, net sales down from $17.26 billion to $12.99 billion, net loss $985 million) and the April 8, 2013 firing: J.C. Penney earnings releases, May 15, 2012 and February 27, 2013, and Form 8-K, April 8, 2013 (SEC EDGAR); TIME, May 17, 2012. The share of goods sold at deep discount before 2012 is as stated by management at the January 2012 launch.
  3. Ullman's return, the apology advertisement, and non-returning customers: contemporaneous coverage, May 2013 onward.
  4. Founding history (Kemmerer 1902; The Golden Rule; associates model): "JCPenney," Wikipedia; Forbes, "From Its Beginnings to Bankruptcy," May 17, 2020.
  5. Chapter 11 (May 15, 2020; about $5 billion in debt, including a $1.25 billion revolver draw in March 2020) and the Simon and Brookfield landlord purchase (about $800 million, approved November 2020): J.C. Penney Form 10-K, FY2019, and Form 8-K, May 15, 2020 (SEC EDGAR); CNBC, May 15, 2020; Financier Worldwide; "JCPenney," Wikipedia.
  6. Wave chronology and closure records (more than 8,000 closures announced in 2017; 9,302 announced in 2019, per Coresight; the 2020 filings cohort; Bed Bath & Beyond's $11.7 billion in share repurchases, fiscal 2004–2022, and 2023 liquidation; Party City's 2023 Chapter 11 and 2024–25 liquidation): Bed Bath & Beyond Forms 10-K (SEC EDGAR); CNN Business, January 8, 2020; contemporaneous coverage (CNBC, Retail Dive, *Fortune*, *San Francisco Chronicle*); "Retail apocalypse," Wikipedia.
  7. Survivor mechanics (Walmart and Target omnichannel build-out; Costco's wage-and-renewal model, with renewal rates of 92.3 percent in the U.S. and Canada and 89.8 percent worldwide in fiscal 2025; TJX, off-price, and dollar-store countertrend): Costco Wholesale Form 10-K, fiscal 2025 (SEC EDGAR); company filings and coverage.
  8. Penney store count today (roughly 650 as of 2025) and going-concern status inside Catalyst Brands (formed January 2025 with Brooks Brothers, Aéropostale, Lucky Brand, and Nautica; owned by Simon and Brookfield): J.C. Penney Form 10-K, FY2019 (SEC EDGAR); Catalyst Brands corporate website; contemporaneous coverage, January 2025.

Corrections and updates

No corrections recorded for this chapter. Found an error? Write to corrections@whytheydied.com and it will be listed here.

Source notes fact-checked 2026-09-23. Updated 2026-09-23